Back • Next Home > Set 11 > Exercise 4

Exercise 4

Here's a fun challenge.  Time travel is supposed to be possible in the Harry Potter books, and some fans have suggested that Dumbledore is really a future version of Ron Weasley.  Let's evaluate that argument:

1. Evaluate this Analysis map:

Click on the image to open it in the editor.  Note: editor will open in a new window.

Hints

• Evaluate the map in this order:

• When evaluating basis boxes ask yourself: What support does this basis provide for the claim above it?
• When evaluating premises ask yourself: Is this true?
• Make sure you evaluate all the premises in a reason or objection before evaluating the reason or objection itself.
• When evaluating reasons or objections ask yourself: Given my assessment of the premises, should I accept this? Is it relevant to the claim above it?
• Finally evaluate the position: what confidence do you have in this given your assessment of the reasons and objection bearing upon it?
• Make sure you've put evaluation icons in all claim boxes, as well as coloring the body of reasons and objections

2. Check your work against the model.

Set 11 - Assessing again • Exercise 1 • Exercise 2 • Larger maps • Exercise 3 • Exercise 4 • Final

© Critical Thinking Skills BV .  Rationale Exercises version 0.1,

Let us know what you think!